Select Page

Differences Between the EPRI TR 102323 Revision 3, 4, and 5

EPRI TR 102323 Revision 3 vs Revision 4

Upon comparing the documents EPRI TR-102323 Rev. 3 and EPRI TR-102323 Rev. 4, several key differences emerge regarding Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) levels and testing procedures.

These updates and refinements in EMC levels and testing procedures between the two revisions show a progression towards more rigorous, up-to-date, and detailed EMC standards suitable for the evolving technological landscape and regulatory expectations.

EMC Testing Standards Updates

Revision 4 of the document introduces the use of the most current versions of endorsed standards unless otherwise specified by the licensee. This reflects an update to maintain consistency with the latest developments in EMC testing procedures, which is not highlighted in Revision 3.

High-Frequency Radiated Electric Field Susceptibility Testing

This specific update is not addressed in Revision 3. Revision 4 updates the upper testing frequency for high-frequency radiated electric field susceptibility under IEC 61000-4-3 from older standards to 10 GHz, accommodating the proliferation of wireless technologies operating within this range.

Surge Testing

Revision 4 endorses IEC 61000-4-18 for testing to Level 3 for systems with cables close to high-voltage bus bar switching hardware. It retains the damped oscillatory waveform from IEC 61000-4-12. This change suggests a nuanced adjustment to better cover specific surge conditions, which were not delineated in Revision 3.

Testing Procedure Consistency

Revision 4 emphasizes ensuring that the testing procedures documented in EMC testing plans are applied consistently to the specific equipment or subsystem, based on military and other industry standards like the Department of Defense’s guidelines.

This detailed procedural adherence ensures equipment compliance across different revisions and is more explicitly stated in Revision 4 than in Revision 3.

Adaptation to Equipment and Test Variability

Both revisions discuss the adaptation to changes in equipment design and testing anomalies but Revision 4 provides a more structured approach towards accommodating design changes and re-testing, which ensures ongoing compliance despite hardware modifications.

EPRI TR 102323 Revision 4 vs Revision 5

EMC Testing Standards Updates

Revision 4 primarily focuses on testing and limits for susceptibility and emissions applicable to both safety-related and non-safety-related components. This includes new wireless device emissions control guidance and modifications to standardized testing limits for susceptibility tests like MIL-STD 461 CS114​​.

EPRI TR 102323 Revision 5 added guidance based on recent industry experiences. This includes new recommendations on exclusion zone calculations, arc welding, and variable frequency drives.

Furthermore, there are additional guidelines for wireless emissions control and a more extensive implementation of the EPRI’s Digital Engineering Guide for decision-making​​.

High Frequency Radiated Electric Field Susceptibility Testing

In the progression from EPRI’s Revision 4 to 5, high-frequency radiated electric field susceptibility testing was significantly expanded.

Revision 4 updated the frequency ranges and aligned with MIL-STD-461E to better address the electromagnetic complexity in nuclear environments. Revision 5 built on this by refining testing standards and enhancing flexibility to accommodate the rise of digital systems and emerging technologies. Both revisions emphasized practical application and adaptability in real-world nuclear facility operations.

Surge Testing

From EPRI’s Revision 4 to 5, surge testing protocols saw important enhancements.

Revision 4 set a foundation by establishing voltage levels for testing surge robustness in nuclear environments. Revision 5 built upon this, introducing more detailed and stringent surge testing procedures to address the vulnerabilities of advanced digital controls. This update ensured a thorough evaluation of how equipment withstands voltage spikes, aligning with contemporary safety and operational standards in nuclear facilities.

Testing Procedure Consistency

Revision 4 of the EPRI 102323 guidelines updated EMC testing procedures to include new testing levels for standards like CS114 and introduced comprehensive guidelines for wireless device emissions, aligning with contemporary technology in nuclear facilities.

Revision 5 expanded on these foundations by extending testing frequency ranges and enhancing alignment with standards such as MIL-STD-461E, ensuring that testing procedures remained thorough and relevant to modern operational demands.

Both revisions consistently integrate feedback to maintain alignment with regulatory standards like Regulatory Guide 1.180, focusing on practical implementations suitable for real-world applications.

These updates collectively advanced the precision and applicability of EMC testing, ensuring robust and effective frameworks capable of addressing the complexities of modern nuclear power plant operations amidst evolving technological and regulatory environments.

Adaptation to Equipment and Test Variability

In Revision 4, the EPRI guidelines adapted EMC testing to the variability of modern electronic equipment, especially with the inclusion of wireless technologies. This revision focused on accommodating the specific characteristics and dynamic nature of new devices within nuclear facilities, ensuring that the guidelines could address potential sources of electromagnetic interference from evolving technologies and operational changes.

This revision aimed to cover a broader spectrum of potential EMI sources. It included considerations for high-frequency interactions and complex device configurations. These enhancements ensure that the guidelines remain relevant and effective. They help manage EMC amidst the integration of advanced technologies into nuclear power operations.

Expert EPRI TR 102323 Testing to any Revision

As a leader in EMC regulatory compliance testing, Keystone Compliance assists electronic equipment manufacturers with EMC testing. Meeting the EPRI, IEC, EN, and other EMC testing requirements can be challenging. Not only do we understand the challenges, but we help guide companies through the process.

Request a quote to see why hundreds of manufacturers trust Keystone with their regulatory compliance testing needs. Have a question about EPRI TR 102323 testing? Contact us and we would be more than happy to help.

For a deeper understanding of the evolution of these testing standards and the specific differences between the revisions, detailed information is available at the provided links: